Jenny McCarthy may be 40 (and certifiably insane) but that didn’t stop her from stripping down for the magazine that made her famous for a heavily airbrushed photo spread that proves midlife crises can be sexy.

I kid. Jenny looks great of course, but she also suspiciously looks exactly the same as when she posed for Playboy 20 years ago. We all know that Hef employs a team of genius Photoshop technicians capable of turning Lindsay Lohan into Marilyn Monroe, but they don’t know when to leave well enough alone. We already saw what a flawless nude 20 year-old looks like the last time Jenny posed for the mag (and in every issue since). It might’ve been nice to see how she actually looks a couple decades later.