Andrew Garcia is Going Down

Andrew Garcia sang Paula Abdul’s “Straight Up” during Hollywood week and it was one of the most memorable performances of American Idol this season.

In fact, because Andrew’s performance was so memorable, apparently none of the Idol judges want to shut up about it! They want him to return to that. Hmmm…. that’s confusing for a singer that has to pick a new song every friggin’ week, all!

Andrew sings Fall Out Boy’s “Sugar We’re Going Down” and it was just the wrong song for the way he remixes songs. It was awkward, strange, and it didn’t compliment Andrew’s voice at all. He sounded like he was whining throughout the song, which should never be because his voice is like butter!